Carrots Will Not Help You See In the Dark - The Truth About Vitamin A


The other day in the breakroom at work a show called The Kitchen (Food Network) was on the TV. They were discussing 100 calorie portions of various foods and one of these foods was carrots.  In their discussion of the 28 baby carrot 100 calorie serving, one of the hosts mentioned that carrots are high in vitamin A. They are not. This got me thinking about how my grandma (and my mom) used to tell me to eat my carrots because they would help me see in the dark. They won't.

Vitamin A promotes good vision and is only found in animal food sources. Plant food sources that are often cited as being good sources of vitamin A contain a precursor to vitamin A called carotenoids. It is possible to convert carotenoids into vitamin A, but the human body is extremely inefficient at this process.

Retinoids vs. Carotenoids

The most important thing to note about vitamin A is the difference between retinoids and carotenoids. The vitamin A you get from from animal sources is in the form of retinoids, also called retinol, while the plant source vitamin A is carotenoids, such as beta carotene.

Animal sources of retinol is bioavailable, meaning your body can use it. The vitamin A from plant sources, however, must first be converted to retinol before your bodycan use it. 

When you are getting most of your vitamin A from carotenoids, you are likely not getting much at all. In an extremely healthy person at least six units of carotenes are required to convert into one unit of retinol. That means you would need to eat 4 1/2 pounds of carrots to potentially get the same amount of useable A as in 3 oz. of beef liver. In someone with digestive issues, hormone imbalances, or other health problems the conversion requires even more units of carotene.

It is also important to note that the carotene to retinol conversion is very delicate and easily compromised. This conversion is negligible in many people. This conversion is virtually insignificant in:

  • Infants
  • Those with poor thyroid function (specifically hypothyroidism)
  • Those with diabetes
  • Anyone on a low fat diet or with a history of low fat dieting
  • Those who have compromised bile production (no gallbladder or other digestive issues) 

Since I've just ruined everything you thought you knew about vitamin A, you're probably wondering where you should be getting it from. 

  • Liver from any animal - enjoy pasture-raised liver 2-3 times per week or take desiccated liver capsules daily
  • Fermented Cod Liver Oil 
  • Regular Cod Liver Oil 
  • Egg yolks from free foraging chickens
  • Butter from grassfed cows
  • Heavy cream from grassfed cows

I have never enjoyed liver, but I eat eggs, butter, and heavy cream so I'm getting some amount of vitamin A. Also, please don't start taking any supplements without consulting your doctor first

The Scoop on Vitamin A

Vitamin A is extremely important for several key functions in the human body. These include:

  • Eyesight
  • Fertility
  • Hormone balance
  • Thyroid function
  • Bone growth
  • Skin health
  • Immune function
  • Cell differentiation
  • Fetal development in pregnant women

You may be concerned about vitamin A toxicity or have heard that it can cause birth defects in infants. While I have not done extensive research on this subject, it appears that most of the studies that link moderate doses of vitamin A to health problems and birth defects used synthetic vitamin A. 

Vitamins taken in pill form should always be done with caution (and with the supervision of a doctor). Often the body does not recognize these synthetic compounds and they can collect in tissues causing toxicity. When you get your vitamins from whole food sources, not only are you getting something that your body recognizes and knows how to use, but you are also getting other vitamins and minerals necessary to efficiently use these nutrients.

It is also important to note that vitamin D is required to help your body utilize vitamin A as well as prevent vitamin A toxicity. Natural sources of vitamin A, such as cod liver oil, also contain adequate amounts of vitamin D in order to help your body appropriately utilize these nutrients. 

Vitamin A is also a fat soluble vitamin meaning that without adequate fat intake your body is not able to absorb this vitamin. Adequate fat intake also helps to increase the finicky conversion of carotenoids into vitamin A. Most foods that are rich in vitamin A also contain the fat needed to utilize it. 

I bet no one was told to eat their liver because it would help them see in the dark!

What did your parents tell you to get you eat your vegetables when you were younger? Share them in a comment...and perhaps I'll even bust a few of them for you!

Who am I?? I am a Family Nurse practitioner with over eight years of clinical experience helping ordinary women cut through all the hype and figure out what actually works for their bodies. If you've ever been told by your healthcare provider that "it's all in your head" or that what you are going through is "normal," I can help! It's not all in your head and just because something is common doesn't mean it is normal.

 Schedule a free consultation so you can get started on your path to optimal health now!

Martha Rosenstein